Home platform lifts are among the most popular wheelchair mobility solutions throughout North America—two of the most popular being hydraulic lifts and electric lifts. While both provide a functional and safe way to move from one level to the next, they differ in noise levels, upkeep requirements, and day-to-day usability for homeowners.
In this short blog, join the RAM team as we break down the insider facts on both electric platform and hydraulic platform lifts. Read on to learn more.
What’s a Hydraulic Home Lift?
Hydraulic platform lifts use pressurized hydraulic fluids to raise and lower the platform. As the lift is activated, the hydraulic pump brings hydraulic fluid into the cylinder. This fluid is incompressible, allowing pressure to raise the piston. As a result of this pressure, the rest of the platform rises with it.
It’s important to note this distinction isn’t about how the platform lift is powered, but rather its drive system. Modern hydraulic wheelchair lifts still use electricity, but in a different way than their electric counterparts.
What’s an Electric Home Lift?
Electric platform lifts, on the other hand, use a motor and standard controls to raise and lower the platform. Once the lift is called, the electric motor begins powering a screw or similar mechanical system to raise and lower the platform between landings.
The Important Ups & Downs
Now that we understand how each home wheelchair lift works, what factors should homeowners consider?
Climate
- If installing your platform lift outdoors, climate is a crucial consideration. Hydraulic fluid is sensitive to temperature fluctuations and may thicken or gel if exposed to the elements. As a result, outdoor wheelchair lifts with hydraulic systems may require protective housing.
Noise Levels
- In homes or quiet residential settings, noise levels can have a significant impact on comfort. Hydraulic platform lifts are often noisier because the hydraulic pump makes noise as the lift moves. Electric lifts, in contrast, tend to operate more quietly as their motors directly drive the platform.
Maintenance
- Maintenance is essential to ensure your lift runs smoothly for years to come. Hydraulic lifts tend to require more substantial maintenance due to sensitive fluid components. Electric lifts also require ongoing maintenance, but are typically less intensive due to fewer complex components.
Odour
- Hydraulic fluid typically has a distinctive oil-like smell. Over time, this odour can become more noticeable as the fluid chemically breaks down. To prevent this, the fluid must be replaced regularly. Electric wheelchair lifts generally avoid these challenges, thanks to a lack of oil-based components.
Space
- Electric platform lifts typically require less space than their hydraulic counterparts. Though hydraulic lifts don’t typically require an entire machine room like an elevator might, they still require extra space to house the hydraulic pump, controller, and other components.
So, Which is Better?
There is no shortage of factors to consider when deciding on a VPL for your home. At the end of the day, we suggest finding a reputable, experienced dealer who will walk you through your options, installation requirements, and necessary considerations.
At RAM, our Flex Lift vertical platform lift utilizes 40 years of industry-leading technologies. The Flex Lift is built with our patented all-electric drive system. To us, electric drive systems offer powerful, consistent performance that’s worthy of the RAM brand.
Accessibility that Fits Your Home
RAM Elevators + Lifts has nearly 40 years of experience manufacturing award-winning mobility solutions, aligned with exceptional quality, code consultancy, and technologies across North America. Let’s elevate your home, one stunning level at a time.
Visit our website to learn more about our residential products and legacy, then contact us today to find a dealer near you.